Showing posts with label darryl broadfoot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label darryl broadfoot. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Incompetent SFA challenge fans to boycott the game

Physical embodiment: The SFA
'Understanding' is a two-way process. To be effective, an organisation needs to listen to the opinions of those with whom it deals and not solely provide information. Issuing a barrage of propaganda is not enough in today's open society.

So say none other that the Chartered Institute of Public Relations as a footnote to their definition of what their organisation is all about:

“Public Relations is about reputation – the result of what you do, what you say and what others say about you.

“Public Relations is the discipline which looks after reputation, with the aim of earning understanding and support and influencing opinion and behaviour. It is the planned and sustained effort to establish and maintain goodwill and mutual understanding between an organisation and its publics*.”

It is a definition that seems to have passed over the Scottish Football Association's heads at high altitude. But then PR is under the direction of the Communications department, which is headed by Darryl Broadfoot.

Broadfoot always seemed a strange choice for such a wide-ranging role. Having worked his way up – with some assistance – to being Chief Football Writer at The Herald, Broadfoot's path to success was one more appropriate to pre-1980s Britain, eschewing university for a much-sought-after job as a teenage “copy boy” at the title.

He was, by all accounts, well-liked – grafting, doing as he was told and giving no one around him an inferiority complex. His football affiliations were well-known by his workmates, which may well have facilitated a close working relationship with David Murray.

But he did as well as could reasonably be expected of someone with his abilities and some might say he deserved praise for that, though few would accuse him of self-sacrifice in the name of journalistic integrity. He was also the man who referred to the “Greek Sagas” and had a brief but infamous association with Michelle McManus, meaning that to the football-supporting public, he was something of a figure of fun.

At that time he seemed incongruous at The Herald but little did we know that his was the shape of things to come with Chris Jack and Matt Lindsay following in his footsteps.

There was little, then, to suggest that he was in any way suited to heading a major department in the national sport's governing body where modern, outward-looking, strategic communication was a key requirement.

It could even be said that only an organisation that would put the likes of George Peat, Gordon Smith and Campbell Ogilvie at its head would be so backward as to appoint a friendly football writer who had paltry education, no qualifications and a very limited relevant skill set.

To communicate with all the SFA's publics, they turned to someone who had spent his entire career with one newspaper, much of it with wiser heads looking over his shoulder.

Is Broadfoot promoting “goodwill and understanding”, in the CIPR's sense of the words? Could anyone say that the SFA enjoys a strong reputation? Or would it be more accurate to say the the Association transmits a “barrage of propaganda”?

The report from John Clark at the Scottish Football Monitor of his meeting with Broadfoot and Alan McRae makes astonishing reading.

First, the President of the SFA is apparently deemed incompetent to answer any of the most pertinent questions put to him. Let's be clear – the Head of Communications may sit in on an interview and occasionally butt in, should the interviewee drop a clanger that requires clarification.

It is not his job to speak for his boss because, quite simply, the boss is supposed to know better than anyone what his organisation is doing. The PR may handle routine press inquiries and briefings but could you imagine, for example, if Alastair Campbell didn't consider Tony Blair capable of outlining Labour Party policy?

There is only one time when such tactics are used and that is when obfuscation or shooting down dissent is required. And that is when the organisation knows it is not on solid ground in its dealings.

Perhaps even more remarkable than Broadfoot's comment, “for the purposes of this meeting, I am the SFA,” which apart from the hubris is a clear indication of McCrae's perceived competence, is what Clark attributes to him about football supporters' concerns being heard:

“Mr Broadfoot opined that the future would show whether Scottish Football supporters were really concerned about the old club/new club debate, if huge numbers turned their backs on the game.”

There, in a nutshell, is the SFA telling fans that if they keep buying tickets they will be ignored. Only by turning their backs on the game will the issues begin to be addressed.

It is rare for any organisation to challenge its own customers to abandon it but that is exactly what the SFA, through Darryl Broadfoot has done. It is over to the fans to respond.

*(“Publics' are audiences that are important to the organisation. They include customers - existing and potential; employees and management; investors; media; government; suppliers; opinion-formers.)

--

Monday, December 22, 2008

EXCLUSIVE: McGeady story sparks tension at crisis-hit Herald

EXCLUSIVE

Only one winner between old guard and ‘Young Turd’

It was the story every sports journalist had been waiting for. Known only to an elite few who browsed the internet from around 9pm on Saturday, The Herald’s Monday edition exclusively revealed that an incident had taken place shortly after Celtic’s draw with Hearts (originally described as a defeat in the newspaper story).

Having caught the rest of the recycled paper part of the industry on the hop, Herald Chief Sportswriter Hugh “Scoop” MacDonald seemed to have scored a coup for his team-mates.

However, we can exclusively reveal that the result has been internecine tension at the crisis-hit Herald.

An impeccable source, speaking on condition of anonymity said: “Darryl is fizzing. I mean how else can you describe the bubbles from his mouth and nose. He feels let down by Hugh.
“He always thought of Hugh as a kindly uncle who would offer professional guidance, try to teach him a bit of punctuation now and then and make constructive suggestions, such as what he should write and how he should write it.
“Then Hugh goes and breaks the only news story The Herald has turned up in the last three years and doesn’t even let Darryl share a byline. You’d have to ask if there’s an agenda.”

Emotions are running high at the troubled title, which has announced that almost all of its editorial staff are at risk of redundancy, prompting some to fear for their jobs.

Our source said: “We all expected Hugh to walk but now it seems that he has notions of breaking news stories before he goes. That can only undermine the rest of the sports desk staff.”

However, we can also reveal that Chief Football Writer Broadfoot, known as “Bombscare” due to his tendency to lose concentration at the most crucial times, is unbelievably one of the highest-paid members of staff at the paper. Said our mole: “He kept getting pay rises to ‘keep him happy’. He even got a rise in return for turning down a transfer to Record PM. It was all very Bobo Balde.”

Now the battle lines have been drawn and it seems that a parting of the ways is imminent but our source revealed that Broadfoot has good reason to worry:

“The trouble is that Darryl has burned a lot of bridges. It all started when he started dating pop stars like Michelle McManus. She seemed to have gone to his head.”

Now, however, having fallen out with predecessor Jim Traynor, the man who once tried to sign him for the PM, Broadfoot’s options are limited. He could theoretically remain at the Herald on reduced terms and conditions or try his luck elsewhere. However, it is thought that his lack of proficiency in English may be a handicap. A move to the internet has not been ruled out.

Both camps seemed to have passed the point of no return last night, with a reconciliation unlikely.

A source close to Broadfoot was recently heard to say: “MacDonald’s values are from the last century. [Darryl] has revolutionised sports journalism with his unique big-page-red-top style. [Darryl] can get exclusives any time I want. No less than a Knight of the Realm has assured [him] that I can have as many stories as I want.”

Friends of MacDonald said he was upset by developments.

“Hugh is adamant he has done no wrong. He was given the story by a guy – we’ll call him Mr M – on strict conditions: ‘Don’t let that wee turd Broadfoot anywhere near it.’ What else could he do?”

It now appears that Broadfoot is having his tantrum in public, ruining the story with clumsy prose. Ultimately, whoever wins, The Herald will be the loser from this undignified spat.

The Herald declined to comment officially.




Seed Newsvine


--

Monday, October 06, 2008

Change of soap for Great Unwashed

Get out your cardiac custard pumps. Make ready the plectrum of your heart-strings.

The Joyless Rangers have been offended – and by Coronation Street. No, really!

Just when you were no doubt convinced by the comedians on Scotland’s Shame favourite website – you know it: the one that has Unionist politicians, Sasha from the Orange Order, Volunteers in the forces and Combatants with a thing for 18 – that the racist song demanding repatriation of the Irish community was a bit of humorous banter, a position supported by Martin Bain and Darryl Broadfoot, suddenly it got serious.

Britain’s favourite Mancunian soap got into bubble with the supporters of the quintessentially British club by showing outrageous bias. As that notorious bigot Tony O’Brien said: "I could no more be interested in Rosie Webster than I could support Glasgow Rangers."

What a horror for fans of the club that doesn’t care that “no-one likes us”.

Before you knew it, there was a change of script because, after all, what could Mancunians have against Rangers?

Fortunately, Lancastrians can expect better and more respectful behaviour from Celtic fans and be thankful that their prayers have been answered regarding Rangers: “Why don’t they stay home?”





Seed Newsvine


--

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

An open letter to Darryl Broadfoot

Dear Darryl,

In the aftermath of a remarkable period in terms of bad blood between your favourite team and mine, let me address some of your recent commentaries in The Herald.

In today’s paper – available on the internet, of course –Artur Boruc wearing T-shirt with pope John-PaulII you spout forth on the actions of Artur Boruc, crassly, if indirectly, linking the wearing of a T-shirt depicting the late Pope John-Paul II to the death of a Celtic supporter attacked on Sunday night.

You also refer to a violent attack, quite possibly sectarian in motivation, on Aiden McGeady remarking, “Suddenly, stoking the fire does not seem such a smart idea, does it?”

Violence, Darryl – sometimes fatal – related to matches between Celtic and Rangers is sadly nothing new. It is something that most decent people abhor, making no distinction regarding the victims or perpetrators of such vile acts.

Yet, you chose not to make mention of the actions of Walter Smith, who, prior to the match, joined with Martin Bain in making direct personal attacks on Peter Lawwell and Celtic in general, scorning the integrity of the club and chief executive and claiming to have been directly disadvantaged by Lawwell’s intervention.

Not so long ago it was accepted that no-one associated with Celtic or Rangers would make any comment likely to raise tensions in the West of Scotland prior to such a match. You apparently seek to imply that Artur Boruc is responsible for fanning the flames yet, by implication of silence, absolve Walter Smith, a veteran of some 40 such encounters as Rangers manager and with an involvement going back 22 years.

Do you think it might have been better for Smith and Bain to have used more temperate language? Why did you make no direct remark on this, other than to add to the “point-scoring” furore?

You also caricature Artur Boruc as a “pantomime villain,” guilty of “overt symbolism,” “antagonism,” “wreaking havoc,” and “selfishness… using football grounds, as a soap box for his beliefs”. That’s a hell of a T-shirt.

It must also be said that your use of the term “granting an audience” in relation to an interview with Boruc is wholly inappropriate. I’ll credit you with the ability to know why.

Has it ever occurred to you or your colleagues to properly challenge the “FTP brigade” who so berated Boruc and reported him to the police for having the temerity to make the sign of the cross at Ibrox Park? Was there a word of condemnation in The Herald when fans at Ibrox displayed a banner degrading Boruc on the grounds of his Catholicism, with the words “Voodoo no worky"?

Apparently not, even though it has been claimed that the banner in question was commissioned by The (non-sectarian) Blue Order, is similar in style to others used by that organisation and appeared in an area used by the group, once the bane of Ibrox officialdom but now quoted as part of the “Follow with Pride” campaign:
“Davie Macintosh of The Blue Order said: ‘I'm really looking forward to hearing the singing even more this season and I'm sure all the fans will be right behind the new Follow With Pride campaign. We are really going to up the anti in terms of stadium atmosphere this season with a few new plans of our own including using megaphones and each stand having its own design of flag.’"

I suspect that the lack of attention to such matters is due to the fact that you, like the majority of Scottish football journalists, seem to consider yourself one of the arbiters of common sense when it comes to defining who has a right to be offended by what and how much.

Then again, derision aimed at Catholicism and Scotland’s Irish community, e.g. the recent song with the words “the famine’s over, why don’t you go home” is routinely displayed by Rangers supporters with barely a line noting its occurrence in the mainstream media.

Despite quoting chapter and verse of the relevant legislation pertaining to Boruc’s T-shirt, and implying that FIFA had been asked to intervene, you conspicuously failed to reference the numerous FIFA and UEFA directives breached by Rangers supporters – and by implication the club – at a significant proportion of the club’s games.

But, Darryl, this is where I have trouble fathoming either what your standpoint is or, perhaps more properly, what inspired The Herald to appoint you as “Chief Football Writer”.

Just last week, you assumed the role of social commentator, scorning people such as yourself (“log-on looneys”, I believe you then called them), “who seek a form of internet-driven infamy; the kind who have taken to inconveniencing UEFA every Monday morning with their pathetic reel of YouTube one-upmanship”.

“Internet idiots are drowning out right-thinking Old Firm majority”, blasted the headline, as you declared “the internet age has spawned a new strain of Old Firm idiocy. Untraceable and unaccountable [We’ll come back to that], this is the evolution of the bampot.”

The “intelligent, reasoned follower of Old Firm fortunes”, you claimed, has had “concise and cerebral arguments drowned out by feverish and irrational proclamations”.

You grossly exaggerated the response of Celtic supporters to Rangers fans unfurling yet another illegal and racist banner at a UEFA Cup match, where the entire ticket allocation had been controlled by the club. You then referred to “the hidden meaning behind ‘Nakamura Ate My Dog’.”

“Racist, discriminatory, the SFA must act was the gist. Are we to assume Celtic's sublimely gifted and profoundly intelligent midfielder has endured sleepless nights over a banner that is not only inaccurate but, given his limited grasp of English, probably lost on him?

“Do we even have to point out that Japanese don't eat dog meat?”

I am sure, Darryl, given your own grasp of English – and a few other usual characteristics of the broadsheet writer – the irony was lost on you but that very night a courageous, gifted and respected journalist, Rageh Omaar, presented the third part of “Immigration: The Inconvenient Truth”. I suggest you watch it before you deign to make any further pronouncements on social cohesion and the acceptable face of racism.

Omaar refers to tabloid headlines accusing Eastern European immigrants of eating swans and relates this common gruesome stereotyping of foreigners to his experience of stories claiming that his fellow Somalis ate donkeys.

The Polish journalist Omaar spoke to said such stories appalled her when faced with the realisation that British journalists “perceive us as wild animals”.

But perhaps we shouldn’t take that seriously. After all, a writer of your standing has already illustrated how the “right-minded majority” should feel, according to their command of English and certain perceptions of what constitutes offensive racism – as opposed to the other kind.

And you clearly feel qualified to pass judgement on Artur Boruc – an immigrant Polish Catholic (and probably, Darryl, the best goalkeeper in the world, in case you can yet be jolted back into the dark realms of sports reporting) who does not easily accept the derision of people who consider themselves to be the natural majority in this country.

“A clear distinction must be drawn between real Old Firm supporters and the plankton who contribute nothing but embarrassment to their respective clubs,” you say, “Those who seek a form of internet-driven infamy”.

There is another clear distinction: “between real journalists and the plankton who contribute nothing but embarrassment to their respective titles” internet-driven infamy being a felicitous side-issue.

Let’s return to fulfilling my promise. “Untraceable and unaccountable,” you say. Well, we could debate who has a right to spout their utterances on the Internet, as you do, and the concept of identity. Does a believable name carry greater weight than one obviously meant to denote an identity without claims that any related passport or driving licence is registered?

Is it more honest to be declared as Darryl Broadfoot than “One Star Means More”, “Fat Eck”, “Hector Bandido”, “Murphio”, “GrandMaster Suck” or “Paul 67”?

What about “Martin McMillan”, “Derek Miller” et al, who beef up the pages of The Herald without indication that they are just two of many Herald "writers" who do not even exist? What about the Herald writer whose reports are listed as “at Stamford Bridge” but who really watches the matches on satellite TV?

The point is, Darryl, if I really have to articulate it, that perhaps we should all try to evaluate what we do, where we are, how the hell we got here and what shaped our perspectives objectively (if we possibly can), lest we face charges of hypocrisy.

Alternatively, rather than taking to the keyboards to attack people and suggest sanctions against them, for example Artur Boruc or those non-journalists who dare to speak, some of us should, as Mr Lincoln advocated, “remain silent and be thought a fool” rather than have our utterances remove all doubt.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Outside Scotland: Sport without religious controversy




Robert Kubica
Brazil football team praying after winnig the World CupBrazil player Lucio with





Seed Newsvine