Showing posts with label Scott Brown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scott Brown. Show all posts

Sunday, March 03, 2019

Who will be the next Celtic manager? The tan and teeth guide to following Brendan Rodgers

It's that time again - and it will probably last for three months.

It's the time when every loon, attention-seeker and "in the know" tosser gives their tuppenceworth on who should be the next permanent manager of Celtic.

Many of the would say that I know little to nothing about football. But I would counter that that makes me as qualified as the most successful football pundits in Scotland, so why not share my wisdom?

(Rather depressingly, many of the names below have been literally copied and pasted from a previous article on this site, at the end of the Ronny Deila era.

So, here goes:

Neil Lennon
Like the vast majority of Celtic fans, I have admired Neil as a player and coach since he was first signed by Martin O'Neill.

That said, I was against his appointment first time round (due to his inexperience) and I wasn't convinced that he would be a huge success when he left us.

But his time with Hibs seemed to demonstrate that he had far greater tactical knowledge than I had given him credit for.

Perhaps being with Hibs, not Celtic, he was more likely to be questioned on what happened in games than pressed for a big headline or perhaps he has just developed but he seems to have shown that he can evolve as a coach, which is a vital quality.

He has also, of course, won three titles and experienced the best and worst that the job can bring.

My personal view: still tending against it but softening somewhat (more on that later.

John Kennedy
There have been rumours that Kennedy is highly regarded by both the players and the board. But is he ready for the big job right now? Probably not.

Marco Rose
One of the more intriguing suggestions. He has worked wonders with Red Bull Salzburg, who took maximum points from our Europa group.

Salzburg also work with a limited budget in a minor league, but with world-leading facilities.

It would be a huge coup but the Bundesliga surely awaits him very soon.

Roberto Martinez
Has been linked before and heavily touted as a candidate.

After a very successful World Cup with Belgium, his stock is high and would be a candidate for any number of top clubs.

Still, he has Shaun Maloney in his coaching staff.

Mark Hughes
The English football pundits' idea of a football manager.

That's why he should manage a team in the lower half of the Premier league or the Championship.

Doesn't know how to smile.

Steve Bruce
See the entry for Mark Hughes above.

Jack Ross
Doing a solid job with Sunderland having been Scotland's manager of the year, last season.

He certainly talks the talk but would be a huge gamble.

John Collins
Absolutely not. Collins has the air of a self-annointed aristocrat of football. Rumours of him rubbing people up the wrong way seem all too credible because he just exudes smugness.

Plus, we must be careful of making white teeth and a permatan a tradition in our managers.

David Moyes
Moyes might well do a good job but he has spent the years since leaving Everton, for the most part, making his own club's supporters cry. I don't think so.

Gordon Strachan
It seems that Gordon probably has no appetite for the intense pressure of the Celtic job again. So, that rules him out.

Martin O'Neill
No doubt he could deliver titles again and may even be tempted to leave the bright lights of Nottingham but it would be very much back to Martin's way, which is not going to progress the club.

Plus, he would bring Roy Keane.

Roy Keane
Let's hope not! The man punches people who ask for his autograph.

In his second autobiography (because one is never enough) he stated that going to Ipswich was a mistake because, having taken the job, he discovered that he couldn't motivate himself to put his heart into a team in blue.

He should be in a secure unit on an island somewhere.

Mick McCarthy
Good old mick. I have a soft spot for him and he gives the impression that he would nut a lamppost if it caught him on a bad day.

I'm not sure that's what the coaching blend needs right now.

Henrik Larsson
Not this again! We all love him and respect him utterly. Let's keep it that way.

Alan Stubbs
He'll reckon he could do the job but recent evidence is that he's a far better pundit than a manager.

Steven Gerrard
On the plus side, he both knows Rodgers's methods and has experience of breaking his heart.

Negatives (too numerous to list) include the fact that he thinks £1m is an eight-figure sum.

Derek McInnes
When hell freezes over.

Michael O'Neill
No doubt his name will crop up again and I wouldn't put it past the board. He's good at what he does with meagre resources but it would be suffocating football.

Malky Mackay
A name only suggested by a mainstream media pundit to stir things up. He would be a PR disaster and has a reputation for liking to spend on players.
But you can bank on his CV already being in.
No.

Steve Clarke
A popular choice who has apparently said that he doesn't want another job in Scotland.

Probably would be very successful and has excellent credentials.

Steve McLaren
Just the sort of tosser Celtic plc would like to foist on us, accompanied by a puff piece on a well-known blog, telling us how smart a move it is.

Paul Lambert
That guy who will always believe that he is a much better manager than he is. He should be managing Aberdeen or a club of similar stature.

Owen Coyle
Would bring all that Bolton and Raith Rovers experience - and appoint someone like Lambert as part of his "dream team".

Jose Mourinho
Made a comment about Rodgers having left at the wrong time and started an Internet rumour in the process. It's one of the more fun rumours but a non-starter.

Arsene Wenger
Let's stick with the silliness. He can certainly coach players, has big-time experience and might even see Celtic as a stepping stone to Leicester some day.

In reality, he'd probably prefer to manage a French or maybe Belgian club and there would be no shortage of offers.

China or the MLS would also be more likely than Celtic.

So, that's just a few of the people who probably have no chance of being the next permanent Celtic manager.

But, going back to Neil, there is a possible scenario in which his appointment works.

I hope for a management team that can retain the best elements of the Rodgers reign but with greater tactical flexibility, the ability to compete in Europe while entertaining without being kicked off the park.

Having worked with Rodgers for two-and-a-half years, John Kennedy will have retained the knowledge of the good things he did - top-level training/coaching, analysis, etc.

But Neil is probably better tactically, equally good at motivating players and has the experience of being in the firing line but delivering a winning team.

So, maybe the Lennon-Kennedy partnership could work for, say two years, with a view to readying John for the big job.

Shaun Maloney might also be enticed to join, bringing his experience of working with Roberto Martinez.

Why not develop a high-tech "boot room" combining all the elements that a modern club - but identifiably Celtic - needs?

If Neil were to agree to step aside in May 2021, the next man to join the group could be Scott Brown, with the hope of three-to-five successful years under Kennedy to prepare him for the job.

The downsides could be that it would look like "all Lawwell's men" and that these plans are never guaranteed to succeed.

However, I'm convinced that we need the above elements and we are unlikely to recruit someone who brings all of them.

So, to quote a famous advert, "It's a long shot but it might just work."

Thursday, July 05, 2018

Celtic in for John McGinn? If you know the history, the move would make sense

Anyone who reads this irregularly-published blog more than twice a year can tell you that I never shy away from saying, "I told you so".

I make no apology for doing so as I simply have a near-perfect memory for those occasions on which I have been proved right.

A cynic might suggest that's because they are so few in number but that's not true.

In fact, they are too many to count on the free fingers of my hands while I type this.

One of those times was my enthusiastic support for Scott Brown, from the outset. Scott's critics are a lot quieter these days but I still have their names in a sealed envelope in my desk.

But the memories some hold of the days when Scott signed (for ten times the price of Kenny Dalglish) seem to have dimmed.

It went like this. Neil Lennon, the most-targeted player in Scotland - by opponents, fans and media alike - was coming to the end of his historic captaincy of Celtic and Gordon Strachan was openly musing that he would leave a gap that would be extremely difficult to fill and perhaps impossible for one man to replace.

What Gordon meant was that he wanted the talented, battling young engine-room of Hibs - Scott and Kevin Thomson - to provide the foundation for the future of Celtic.

We now know that Celtic's Peter Lawwell allowed himself to be beaten to the punch by Walter Smith, seeing Thomson head off to Ibrox, by his own admission, taking the first offer to get away from John Collins.

Many - not least Derek Johnstone - expected Scott to follow his close pal and team-mate but the player had other ideas. Massimo Donatti - a good servant to Celtic - was recruited by Celtic's clever scouting operation deeming him a player who could do what Thomson did.

Apparently, this cleverness had omitted to account for the impact on both players and Celtic's ability to replace Neil with what might have been to Celtic and Scotland a midfield partnership to be spoken of with the same relish as the centre-backs, Miller-and-McLeish, was to Aberdeen and Scotland fans in the 1980s and 90s.

Personally, I had always quietly admired Thomson, though I much preferred Scott. (I recall an English friend spluttering that Thomson must be a player if I was complimenting a guy who had played for Rangers.)

While I may have digressed, Celtic are coming to another watershed moment, though planning for it with rather more foresight than when Scott was thrust into one of the most unforgiving positions Scottish football could offer and basically told: "Perform!"

Referees and a minuscule sense of fair play permitting, Scott's legs have a few seasons left to run but the void that he will leave will be no smaller than when Neil hung  up his boots for Celtic.

He is Celtic's captain, unquestioned leader, icon and, in this blogger's opinion, still our best player.

So, we do need to plan for that sad day when Scott finally takes his last bow for Celtic.

And it would be utter folly to try to find a replacement at the time. A comparable player would be far beyond the means of Celtic and, even then, by no means guaranteed to make that step  successfully, never mind immediately.

So, we absolutely must plan for a slow transition. And that's where John McGinn comes in.

Forget false comparisons between McGinn and Stuart Armstrong, which many have made. Armstrong has all the technical tools to be a top footballer but had never shown the stomach to be a Celtic captain or midfielder ready to take responsibility for all the good and bad that may happen to the club.

And, aside from that fact, they are players of very different styles.

The more direct comparison with Armstrong would be the vastly-superior Olivier Ntcham, who is a footballer of the highest quality. So much so that I believe that next summer's clamour will be for the signature of Olivier.

To turn a metaphor on its head, Olivier could be described as a velvet fist in an iron glove. He has such a good touch with both feet, as well as superb balance and reading of the game, yet his powerful physique enables him to show these skills when under intense physical pressure.

He shares many of these attributes with Moussa Dembele and these are highly-prized at the top levels of the modern international game.

So, appreciate Olivier while he is here, as I expect Europe's top clubs to be using a battering-ram on Celtic's front door, rather than knocking.

That leaves Eboue Kouassi, for whom I still retain hope. Eboue has made two massive cultural changes in just a few years, going to Russian and then to Scotland before he was twenty.

So, it shouldn't be a great surprise that he hasn't made a major impact in a year-and-a-half.

Eboue is another obvious contender to assume the mantle of Scott but, as with Neil Lennon, replacing our captain may be too big a job for one man (even, if for some different reasons).

So, we come to Hibernians' John McGinn.

Is he as good as Scott? Let me join in with those wailing, "No!", as if any player in Scotland could be, with Scott having swept all awards last season.

Could McGinn be as good as Scott? With similar dedication and excellent coaching, I think it's possible.

I do think that Scott had a bit more than McGinn when he came to Celtic. Then again, I had rarely seen a player with that unstoppable dynamism that Scott possessed, coupled with his instinct to create an attack when, in those days, he invariably rose first from a crumple of bodies and immediately looked to play the ball forward.

But I do see huge potential in McGinn and, given great coaching and top-level experience, I think that he has what it takes to develop into a future Celtic captain.

It's easy to forget that the coaching of Gordon Strachan and Brendan Rodgers, in particular, coupled with Scott's own maturing and intelligence have combined to produce a player who I wouldn't swap for anyone else in the world.

The criticism of McGinn saddens me, not least because of its merciless negativity.

As the great Tommy Burns once said, you should always focus on what a player CAN do for you, instead of what they can't.

John McGinn - the best player in Scotland last season, outside Celtic - can already do plenty of things in midfield.

Learning from Scott and coached by Brendan, I would like to see what else his game has to offer in green  and white.

The Hooped kind, of course.
--

Sunday, May 20, 2018

A day of thanks – to Brendan Rodgers, the Celtic players and especially to Scott Brown

I missed out on Lisbon. I was too young to appreciate nine-in-a-row. I had to make do with stories, pictures and films telling of the legendary Lisbon Lions and how they took on the world and won. Of the Quality Street Gang who helped Celtic dominate Scottish football from the late 60s to mid-70s.

Having gone through good times and bad, my favourite Celtic memory had been the centenary double – thirty years ago, this year – when Billy McNeill came back as a saviour and delivered us the league and Scottish Cup.

That will always remain in my heart and be tied to the names of true Celtic greats – Bonner, Aitken, McStay and, of course, the peerless Tommy Burns.

That season was special, not just for the victories, but because a club as great as ours surely deserved something tangible on our 100th birthday. We have won doubles since, but none have ever mattered to me quite as much.

But time has taught me to try to appreciate success as it happens. To value the special people while they are with us.

While celebrating our glories, we never quite know what lies ahead and we must take each and every one on their own merits, while never ceasing to hunger for more.

So, firstly, we must remember that seven titles in a row is a monumental achievement in itself and not merely a component of something bigger.

And, secondly, when we have won two consecutive domestic trebles, we should enjoy the fact that our players, manager and staff have brought us our own “Lisbon moment”.

We could rhyme off the players who have put in stellar performances over the last two seasons and further back over the seven titles.

But none come close to Scott Brown in terms of what he has achieved and given to Celtic since he arrived from Hibs all those years ago.

Courage, skill, strength, determination, energy, leadership.

All these qualities have taken him on the long journey from a dynamic midfielder with great promise towards taking his place amongst the all-time great Celtic players and captains.

Just as in 1988, it seemed that the footballing gods had shone their light down on us to grant us a glory we deserved, those same powers seem to have delivered a fitting accolade to Scott in his testimonial season.

Celtic seven-in-a-row and double-treble-winning captain.

From one fan to all our people but especially to Scott Brown – thank you.--

Tuesday, April 03, 2018

Scottish referees need competence, not commentators' idea of "common sense"

Where your writer attempts to use fast food analogies in order to draw lessons relevant to Scottish football.

There has been much talk in Scotland - again - about that old chestnut known as "common sense".

You know the drill.

There is a controversial decision - very often by virtue of nothing other than the fact that it benefits Celtic, either directly or indirectly through its perceived impact on a would-be rival.

(Recently around Cédric Kipré's red card for putting his studs into Scott Brown, to which “common sense” said he should not have been sent off and eventually prevailed with the card being rescinded.)

The pundits are inflamed. They disagree.

What is the rule?

Usually these professional analysts, most of whom have played the game, haven't got a clue. (Why would you expect people who are supposed to be enhancing the knowledge of millions of viewers to spend time learning the rules?)

There is a heated argument, which may be the most entertaining thing that has happened on the show.

How do we resolve this? Let's pour oil on troubled waters by calling for "common sense".

Yes, the pundits and presenters nod, wise words. "Common sense".

Surely, we can all agree on that.

But can we?

Do you ever stop to consider what that really means?

In our personal lives, of course we know.

"Whatever happens, don't disturb me," a relative says. Later they find that their car has gone.

"What happened?"

"The police towed it. I was going to tell you but you said not to disturb you."

"Have you no common sense?"

So far, so easy.

But take another case – your favourite guilty secret fast food joint. It's 10.15 am and you really fancy your favourite breakfast bun that's available until 10 – but they have one on the rack and your server agrees it is only common sense to sell it to you.

Mmmm... You know you want it but do the rules allow it?

"Eh, excuse me," a customer in the next queue says to a staff member, indignantly, "When I asked for that, I was told that your rules stated I couldn't buy it after 10 o'clock."

"I was just doing what I'm paid to do," his server explains.

"I was only using common sense," says your server.

"Or maybe there's something about me that you don't like," says the increasingly-frustrated customer.

"You're paranoid," you and the two staff members retort in unison.

The manager saunters in.

"Look, let's not get silly about this. Both of my staff were doing their jobs honestly and to the best of their ability. I fully support both of them and I think this criticism is unfair on people doing a job that few would envy."

Meanwhile, the other customers have become interested and are taking sides.

"That wee jobsworth is always like that," someone shouts, "He had ten Big Brekkies there last week and wouldn't sell me one of them at two minutes past!"

"Oh, really!" pipes another, "Well Mr Common Sense here did the same to me yesterday. It's only 'common sense' for those and such-as-those with that so-and-so."

By this time, the manager is becoming increasingly defensive, while you are preparing to take your swag away.

"You know, serving you people is a thankless task that I wouldn't wish on anyone."

"Just train them to be consistent!"

"Just hire people with common sense!"

"Aye, common sense when it suits YOUSE!"

As chaos ensues, a crestfallen woman with a clipboard identifies herself as being from the regional quality assurance team.

"I would like to say that I recognise the frustrations expressed here and sincerely regret them.
"While the rule on selling Big Brekkies after 10am may seem pedantic, we ask all our branches to observe it for a number of reasons.

"Firstly, sandwiches still on the rack at 10am show a higher dissatisfaction rate, which is difficult to remedy as our entire production setup moves to lunchtime meals at 10 o’clock.

"Secondly, we believe that our customers deserve a consistent service across all our branches and we find that leaving these seemingly-small decisions to local level can leave customers disappointed over matters that may not be immediately obvious."

"Really?" says the manager, "And who even asked you?"

Forgive the parable – and before going further I should make two points.

Firstly, of course no reasonable person has had more than a small portion of their morning spoiled by disappointment over which fast food they were allowed to buy, so the example is frivolous.

Secondly, there is not a burger joint, pie shop or chippie – never mind chain – in the country that is not run and staffed far better than any of the Scottish football authorities.

At the weekend, common sense – or, more importantly, “commentators’ sense” visited Fir Park where Motherwell (again) hosted The Rangers.

Well were awarded a penalty, much to the indignation of professional controversialist, Chris Sutton, and the world’s wealthiest horticulturist Ally McCoist.


A kick is not a (penalty) kick. Unless it's really hard!

“Never a penalty!” “Soft!” “There’s contact but not enough.” “There is a kick but not hard enough!”

Well, that appeared to be that, despite what you may have seen watching at home.

Two former professionals – one ex-Celtic, one ex-Rangers – made their statements of ecumenical unanimity.

Nick Walsh had got it wrong and Curtis Main cynically took advantage to make it 1-0 to Motherwell.

Then – Oh, the Humanity! – Allan Campbell had the Claret-and-Ambers 2-0 up in 16 minutes.

Well dominated the first half but Sutton and McCoist – neither of whom had ever “been professional” in “drawing fouls” in or around the box, were gagging on the injustice of that wrongful pen.

What happened next was as lamentable as it was predictable.

Eight-million-pound-man James Tavernier took the first opportunity after half-time to theatrically land on his bahoochie and – peep-peep-point! – it’s a penalty.

Again Sutton and McCoist agreed – never a pen! – but Tav didn’t care. Poetic justice!
Two minutes later, Jamie Murphy popped in a peach and it was 2-2.

Honest Tavernier had no intention of going down

Well’s top-six ambitions virtually shattered, The Rangers still looking good for a top-four-or-better finish to the season.

All is apparently right with the world, except for the referee.

Now, I already know what a good five-to-seven of my ten (or more) regular readers are thinking: that referee Walsh was just biased -  he couldn’t wait to even it up.

And you’d be at least half-right.

But, by full-time, something else had happened. McCoist had changed his mind about the first penalty and the rest of the panel, except for Sutton, agreed that Walsh had got it spot-on! (Pun champion since 2006.)

Just another day in the professional backwater that is Scottish football.

However, in homage to that legal great, Tony Petrocelli, let me present you, ladies and gentlemen, with another version of what happened that day.

Petrocelli tells it like it is.


Your eyes did not deceive you when you believed that Russell Martin had kicked Chris Cadden on the calf, missing the ball by some margin of both space and time, thus constituting a penalty.

But what happened at half-time behind closed doors in the referee’s room?

I submit to you that poor Nick Walsh, as officials regularly do, ate the forbidden fruit of half-time roundups put on BT Sport (on this occasion, instead of Sky), either on a TV or personal mobile device, and found that he had been roundly castigated for a crucial decision by two high-profile “expert” commentators from either side of a divide that last existed in 2012.

He was now going to be the subject of much criticism, given the importance of the game for both clubs and, faced with the prospect of a media barrage for days after the game, he allowed human weakness to take over.

I believe that he really couldn't wait to even things up, as the punters often say, but probably not because he was following a tradition of institutional bias.

His first-half performance had been very good.

But he listened to the opinion-formers and buckled, throwing bad decision after good because neither Chris Sutton nor Ally McCoist either know or care about the rules of the game. (After all, in their playing careers, they had someone on the pitch to take care of that.)

In other words, because he made a good decision that pundits didn't understand, he felt compelled to "compensate" by making a bad decision to make amends. 

That, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, is modern Scottish football. The media influencing decisions on the field and actively making things worse.

McCoist later admitted that he was wrong. Doing likewise doesn’t fit with Sutton’s persona.

But, again and again, in the Scottish game, refereeing decisions are made that defy the international rules, which are intended to offer some semblance of consistency and an even playing field.

That’s how it becomes “common sense” to absolve Kipré of a correct red card (only in Scotland would it not have been a clear red) and Andrew Davies can perform what was definitely a reckless and dangerous "challenge" on Scott Brown - but which looked like a deliberate and malicious assault - and get a single-match ban.

Another accidental attack on Scott Brown

Because, you see, there is really no such thing as common sense.

Well, there is but it exists in each of our minds in different forms according to our wishes and needs at any specific time. And that is the same as inherent bias. 

Rules governing a game are intended to ensure that those inconsistent interests don't offer advantage or disadvantage unfairly.

So that one player isn't protected while another is assaulted; one freed of suspension while another is banned for an identical or lesser offence.

Play isn't - or shouldn't be - stopped for some head injuries but not others. Because, even when a player's health and safety is at stake, he is at the mercy of what that particular referee considers "common sense" - the catch-all excuse for not doing his job.

I have little sympathy for referees and assistant referees in Scotland as their general standard of officiating is appalling.

I also find it both incredible and offensive that Scottish referees are still considered incapable of the corruption that the media are all too happy to believe pervades football in countless overseas countries.

But the atmosphere that is created in Scotland is toxic to any hope of the raising of standards or fair play in general.

The biased and ignorant, through their media influence, too often dictate the implementation of the rules of the game.

We don't need common sense dictated by part-time weekend entertainers. We already have rules. 

We just need the officials to apply them in Scotland properly, without the pundits telling them not to.

Imagine that - Scottish football being governed by the rules and standards that apply to the rest of the world.

Wouldn't that just be common sense?

Monday, March 19, 2018

Sky's Andy Walker - cheat, hypocrite ... pathetic!

Self-confessed cheat Walker has a short memory. Scott Brown needs no lectures from Sky’s hypocritical commentator

Celtic captain Scott Brown is the man opposition fans love to hate. That’s, more often than not, a good sign as it means they know the player will cause their teams problems.

But we should not forget that he is also the man opponents love to kick, and who coaches and pundits love to criticise and condemn.

Brown has been by far the best Scottish player of his generation and yet, virtually every week, we see some new infraction that he is supposed to have committed.

No doubt some will say that he “brings it on himself”, like another Celtic captain was said to do when he was faced with the worst sort of abuse and intimidation.

But, unlike at some other clubs, the captaincy of Celtic doesn’t seem to afford a player any respect from those outside the club – Scott was farcically omitted from the Player-of-the-Year shortlist last season, despite being arguably the best in the country – and that’s all the more reason why Celtic fans should be careful about being drawn into attacking him.

At the weekend, it was Motherwell’s Cédric Kipré who was the apparently innocent victim of Scott’s malevolence. They collided, Scott gave him a slight shove on the shoulder as he rose, Kipre responded by kicking him.

Brown, who had only half-risen, went back down and looked to the referee, who sent Kipré off.

It wasn’t a hard kick, admittedly. But, to some, that seems to make it allright.

And to Sky’s Andy Walker, who has a personal history with Scott, it was the Celtic captain’s “pathetic” reaction that got the French player red-carded.

Did Scott roll around pretending to be hurt? Did he wave an imaginary card demanding action? No?

Did he expect Kipré to be sent off? Probably not.

But, as probably Scotland’s most-kicked and least-protected player, apparently calling the referee’s attention to a deliberate off-the-ball kick is a crime worthy of trial by media and many Celtic fans have taken the bait.
Kipre puts his studs into Scott Brown

(And let's not forget that Motherwell's captain Carl McHugh later received no punishment for taking Tom Rogic out, missing the ball by some margin, while on a yellow card.)

Don’t get me wrong – I have no time for diving, histrionics, pretending to be hurt, “card,waving” or any other of the cynical behaviours that have become part of modern football and I have no wish to see Celtic players indulge in them.

But to blame Scott for Kipré’s card – saying that it was his reaction that got him sent off – is comparable to blaming someone who reports a crime which a judge later views more seriously than expected.

No, Kipré got himself sent off because this man, who is barely a footballer, uses physical intimidation and dangerous fouls as the only apparent weapons he has in his professional armoury (which is why he is in the Motherwell team) and has not yet learned that lashing out is unacceptable on a football pitch.

It is a lesson that a young Scott Brown learned against Neymar, who unlike Scott, reacted as if he had been beaten with a baseball bat.

Scott’s reaction, while receiving unusual sympathy from several pundits, was to accept full responsibility.

But let’s take a moment to consider Walker, who set the media agenda on this story, as being first to publicly comment always has the opportunity to do.

Many seem to have forgotten how many times Walker admitted “going to ground” as a player and defending his right to do so.

For example, when reacting to a Bayern Munich victory over Manchester City, Walker said:

“I did it on occasion. I don’t think I was flamboyant as [Arjen] Robben but if I wanted to make sure the referee had seen what I thought was a foul I would choose not to stay on my feet and go to ground.

“I would put pressure on the referee - what do you think ref? Is this a penalty or not? And sometimes it would go for you.

“A lot of people will say that’s cheating but I think cheating's part of the game, as unpleasant and distasteful as that sounds.”

Yes, it does sound distasteful, Andy. Scott Brown is not a cheat but you certainly were.

In fact, Andy – you’re pathetic.

--

Monday, February 26, 2018

Scott Brown is an all-time great Celtic captain – his Scotland retirement is good news

It may be a very long time before we have such a top-class player commit ten years to us again

There is one great advantage to being a blogger.

When you are right, you can quote yourself, with links and unbearable smugness, confident that most readers are too disinterested in your output to find all the times you've been wrong.

On Scott Brown, just about all of my comments have been in the former category and I'm a happy chappie today because I get to remind you of that again.

But, more importantly, I'm hugely relieved that Scott has chosen to retire from international football. (Ironically, shortly before Scott previously announced his international retirement, I had suggested the same thing.)

Scott clearly has a passion for the Scotland team that not all Celtic fans share, so I'm sure this is a day of mixed emotions.

But it is right for the player and that's a huge boost for the team.

You only have to look at Celtic without Scott, as in the insipid 0-0 draw with St Johnstone, to see how vital he is to everything Celtic do.

The intensity that Brendan Rodgers calls for comes from him, he takes the ball under pressure when his teammates are in trouble and turns defence into attack.

With the players under Brendan understanding where they should be on the pitch , Scott's pass completion rates have matched the finest players in Europe.

He can win the ball and seems to fear nothing but he has always had sharp attacking instincts. He has an enviable array of passes and can play-one-touch football at pace.

And he is also the only true leader we have on the pitch (with Kieran Tierney being the next best in that department).

And if that's all fawning praise, I don't mind that. More than ten years after signing for Celtic, Scott has taken his place amongst the all-time great Celtic captains alongside the likes of Billy McNeill, Danny McGrain, Roy Aitken and Tommy Burns while, as a footballer, he is the best central midfielder we have had since Paul McStay.

He has had his detractors in the past but they are mostly silent now. Few fans, let alone bloggers, wish to remind you that they once wanted him sold or considered an expensive player from Hibs not to fit with the plan.

But he has stayed, proven his quality and it may be a very long time before we have such a top-class player commit ten years to us again.

The announcement is good news for Celtic as we need Scott more than ever.

Now all we need is for Brendan Rodgers to learn his name properly. It's not Brownie, it's Broonie!

--

Sunday, October 16, 2016

What about the plan, Celtic? The vindication of the fools


It was announced on Friday, with no fanfare whatsoever, that John Park had left Celtic.

John Who? The majority of Celtic fans who have taken a close interest in the club’s operations over the past few years will know the name well.

Football Operations: John Park and Peter Lawwell
Having been at Hibs and credited with the discovery of Scott Brown, Kevin Thomson, Derek Riordan and Garry O’Connor, among others, it wasn’t surprising that Park would have been seen as an attractive target for Celtic. What club wouldn’t want a guy who had a track record of unearthing local talent that went on to earn international caps?

I should state here that no criticism of John Park is implied – I have no doubt that he did hs job exactly as he was expected to do.

However, despite constant denials from Celtic – and successive coaches, who may have been contractually obliged not to comment on negative aspects of the workings of the club – suspicions remained that Park’s role was not always consistent with the footballing aims of the manager/head coach, whatever we are supposed to call him.

The alarm bells first started to ring shortly after Gordon Strachan left the club. Overall, Strachan did an exceptional job for us and should be thanked for that. However, shortly after he left he made a cryptic statement indicating that he would never again sign a player he hadn’t seen.

During Strachan’s time, Celtic signed Thomas Gravesen and Roy Keane – both of whom he had assuredly seen, but neither of whom he apparently wanted.

Keane, in his inimitable style, went on to say that his future manager’s absolute disinterest in having him as a player was an extra motivation to sign – an “up you, Gordon!”

Gravesen was a different case in point, altogether. Stilliyan Petrov had gone to Aston Villa, having been kind enough to sign a contract with Celtic, meaning that the club would get £7.5 million pounds for him, when he could have landed a much fatter deal by letting the contract run down.

Gravesen was then brought in, meaning that Celtic landed a Galactico to replace Petrov, and pocketed a whopping profit at the same time. Great!

Gravesen was a tremendous player – built like a brick sh*t-house, with an irrestible drive and energy that allowed him to dominate the middle of the park. In that regard, he was much like Victor Wanyama but he also had an attacking instinct and a powerful shot that persuaded Real Madrid that he could transpose those qualities to La Liga.

But there was a problem – Gordon didn’t want him and this established pro was neither able nor willing to change his style of play to suit the more controlled passing game that Strachan favoured.

It still seems surreal to recall that many people thought that Gravesen wasn’t good enough for us. He certainly was – but RIGHT for us at the time; maybe not.

Roy Keane was a different case altogether. Keano is one of a select band of players who I admired greatly in a pre-Celtic career before finding that the reality of him in a Celtic shirt was one inextricably-linked to an image of him as an utter ******le.

Both Keane and Gravesen were known quantities – but the warning signs were there. Our manager was being asked to work with players he didn’t know – like Du Wei, for example.

Many of us rang the alarm bells at the time but we were mocked by those who thought themselves the more “intellectual” Celtic fans. You know them – the ones who talked about “The Plan”.

The Plan (as another blog noted this week) seemed to involve John Park being a de facto Director of Football, with Peter Lawwell doing the contract stuff while Park identified the players in his “roving” role.

We were told that this was what was needed, rather than the "homespun" approach of Celtic managers signing players they have identified.

We signed some good players – Forster, Wanyama, Van Dijk – and sold them to Southampton as soon as they offered eight figures. For this, Peter was rewarded greatly and, we must presume, Park was, too.

We also signed players who would walk into the all-time Hall-of-Guff, should such a thing ever exist. But that didn’t seem to matter – six flops were more than offset by one £10m pay-off.

Those of us who protested were decried as fools. We were asked how much money we wanted to spend and told that amount would bankrupt the club – even though we had never answered the question.

We were reminded of the mantra of The Plan, an entity lauded by the followers of one site (who routinely referred to its owner as if he was a knight of the realm). Those who couldn’t or wouldn’t sign up to said scheme of modernism were labelled as naive, wreckers who would see the club bankrupted.

There was to be no middle-ground between reckless spending and feckless recruitment with a view to player-trading being the primary function of the club.

We were reminded of Porto – we never came close to Porto’s achievements.

“Celtic fans” -- the new kind who understood business better than the common-or-garden “beggin’-yir-pardon-sir” plebeians – told us that the balance sheet was what mattered most of all.

What – you want to watch a good team, playing good football with aspirations to raising the standards year-by-year? “I suppose you think we should spend £12m on the likes of Tore Andro Flo? No? How much should we spend - £20m, £30m? Do you have any idea how well we’re run?”

Buy your ticket and shut your mouth was the mantra.

And yet – look what has happened.

The Plan has changed. Why? (Whisper it.) Because The Plan failed.

The Plan, which saw Celtic radically under-invest in the post-Rangers years, also brought Euopean failure, fans expressing apathy and anger, the club giving the Head Coach’s job to a virtual rookie and key players in the squad sold from under him.

And what was the response to this failure?

That is something you are never likely to hear from the “new realists” who lavished praise on the Celtic knight, while they munched their prawn sandwiches, laughing about their pie-eating, team-on-the-park days.

How many dissenters ever said we had to spend £10m-£20m, however hard the saints of Peter’s rapid news site asked? Few, if any. On the other hand, many welcomed the change of approach for this season.

A manager – not just Head Coach – who is in charge of the football operation because he understands it better than anyone. I’ll admit that I wasn’t convinced that Brendan Rodgers would be the best choice for us because I’ve always been suspicious of “highly-regarded” picks.

I cannot give him the backing that he has given to Scott Brown as both regular readers of this blog will know that I never give more that 100% to anything – it’s illogical.

But what have we seen – Moussa Dembele, who had shown his potential in the English Championship, persuaded to come to Celtic for the next stage of his development.

This was not part of The Plan.

Those of us who are old enough need only cast our minds back to the tears Henrik Larsson shed when it seemed as if Feyenoord would scupper his move to Celtic. That was not to do with love for Celtic at that time but, as Henrik said, he had seen how Pierre Van Hoojidonk had developed.

Neither was it part of The Plan – it was a straightforward reaction by a player who had potential, recognising that he could emulate or exceed Van Hoojidonk’s achievements, if only given the chance.

That’s one of the reasons why Dembele is such a great signing for us. It’s not just because we have such an exceptional player (whose comments on receiving player-of-the-month were just what every Celtic fan would love to hear).

But, when Moussa signed, Zinedine Zidane said it was a logical move for a player he had been watching. Zizou said he had to score in the Champions League – Moussa duly scored. France Under-21 caps – two goals in two games, drawing praise from Didier Deschamps, who has already discussed bringing him into the top squad.

This seems lost on some people – we have a manager who was influential in the development of Raheem Sterling and Luis Suarez and who Steven Gerrard described as the best one-to-one coach he had ever worked with.

His initial work with Dembele will also be noted by other players whose aspirations match Moussa’s – to play in the Champions League and get the attention of the coach of one of the elite European national teams.

If Moussa can get his full call-up for France, why couldn’t any other French, German, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese or English player seek to follow his path at Celtic?

That wasn’t The Plan – find some potential, give them a couple of seasons to show their licks, sell the best for big money. Figure out what to do with the rest.

The Plan would never have brought Henrik to Celtic and this is the time for those criticised for objecting to it, to recognise that.

There are two other distinctly “off-plan” signings but the sort who idiots like me always sought (you know, we were hell-bent on the destruction of the club).

Signing Kolo Toure did not fit The Plan. He was a “diminishing asset” before Brendan Rodgers persuaded him to leave Liverpool, where fans expected him to be offered another contract.

What Kolo has become is more than a defensive rock – he is the defensive coach in-situ; the guy who knows exactly what has to be done, where players should be and the decisions they should make. Any defender who doesn’t learn from playing with Toure will demonstrate much about his future potential.

(In this, he is adding value to his defensive cohorts, Plan followers.)

And the third “off-plan” player is – of course Scott Sinclair. Sinclair epitomises something else that we should be seeking to exploit – a player with abundant skill, who has had a hiatus in his career, but who an astute manager can assist towards fulfilling his full potential.

Players like Scotty don’t make any sense according to The Plan – you take someone who is paid a massive salary and invest a great deal to persuade him that he should come to Celtic and, if he has sufficient belief, might flourish again; even maybe play in the Champions League.

Once upon a time, it was Chris Sutton – devastating with Norwich City and Blackburn Rovers – but discarded by a too-rich club who paid £10m for him while most of the English media chose to forget how good a player he was.

Chris Sutton is one of the best Celtic players I have seen with my own eyes. Scott Sinclair need only look to him for inspiration.

There is, though, a fourth issue, and that is about keeping players. For that, look no further than Kieran Tierney. With major clubs said to be ready to offer in the region of the magic £10m, Kieran actually chose to sign a long-term deal with Celtic, the club he supports.

I’m not the only Celtic fan who gulped a little bit of emotion when KT chose to stay with us, a Celtic supporter ready to fulfill his dreams in a Celtic shirt. But again, many of us suspect that the prospect of working with off-Plan Brendan Rodgers was significant.

This is not The Plan – but neither are Celtic facing bankruptcy. In fact, the club is enjoying just the sort of financial rewards hoped-for by non-Plan exponents, while The Planners were espousing the benefits of the Europa League, instead of the other tournament we were supposed to qualify for, three years out of five.

It is worth remembering that nothing has been won this season. Fans and players need to be conscious of that. And it was wonderful to hear Pep Guardiola defining what it means to pull on a Celtic shirt – to win every week. When Pep is paying homage to the values of the club, it can also serve as a reminder that complacency never fits with being a Celtic player.

We respect the opposition, no matter who they are, and play to win.

We know that we do not have a divine right to win and that every point or victory must be earned on the park.

These are the values and ethos of the club – not any immutable Plan, supported by people who could well be called propagandists.

A proper manager who knows what he is doing (with astutely-chosen professional assistants), leading the football operations of the club – in charge of signing policy.

That’s not The Plan – but it’s what reckless fans like me thought could work, all along.

Some Celtic “fans” probably hope we’re wrong.

Wednesday, September 14, 2016

Philosophy - and irrefutable proof that fans make football

"Thou great star! What would be thy happiness if thou hadst not those for whom thou shinest!"
 - Thus Spake Zarathustra

It is now so ingrained in the ethos of Celtic fans that anyone who couldn't quote Jock Stein declaring that the two greatest teams in the world, without fans, are nothing would be viewed with deep suspicion.

The smart knew him to be right; the wise wouldn't have needed him to tell them.

But if any doubted the great man, they need only have witnessed Celtic playing Atletico Madrid behind closed doors, in 1985, to understand how surreal and lacking in entertainment value football without fans is.





Contrast the two occasions and results.

In one, in a hostile atmosphere, Celtic produced an excellent result. In the surreal return leg, the absence of Celtic fans was Atletico's edge.

This was, of course, a hangover from one of the worst experiences of my life supporting Celtic - the shameful Rapid Vienna affair.

Celtic were treated unjustly by UEFA but some fans were suckered, too. And how ironic that the actions of a few fans should have had such a history-defining effect on Celtic's future.

It would not be until the reign of Martin O'Neill that European football would be a positive experience for the club.

It is the presence of tens of thousands of fans, packing stadiums, that makes football and a few can undermine the experience for everyone. We have seen much of this over thelast week.

I was looking forward to the match on Saturday and, of course, very keen that Celtic should win. I explained as much on this blog.

But, however hard some try to say otherwise, I didn't have the butterflies, the anxiety or the adrenal excitement that preceded matches with the real Rangers.

None of that - the stupid superstitions, the rituals, the trying to find reassurance from other Celtic fans that we had enough to win - was there.

Yet, we witnessed a fantastic occasion.

And why? Because the ground was full and bouncing.

Tuesday was as cringe-inducing a night of football as you could ever witness. In fact, it was the sort of score against Celtic that I have always hoped never to witness.

But while the anticipation, rapidly metamorphosed into shock and then a worrying, helpless sense of inevitability, the sounds of the crowd made a no-contest into an event.

Because fans, without football, can watch Bake-Off but football, without fans, is nothing.

I have a friend who once played bass with a successful band. (He's not personally famous but  he had his moment in the sun.) He told me that the clichés about performance were true:

"The crowd gives you energy; you give it back to the crowd and then they give it back to you - amplified!"

And this was what we witnessed on Saturday – and on Tuesday (though Tuesday's recipients were not in green and white).

Yes, the game with The Rangers was a grudge match - it had added "local derby" spice and the premature rhetoric had cranked that up.

But it was neither our most difficult nor important match of the season so far. It wasn't even the most serious SPFL test, but Celtic fans spent the rest of Saturday smiling, laughing, celebrating - energised.

But that's not the whole story. All of us who have followed football know there is a joyful difference between witnessing players who can revel in such an atmosphere and those who wilt.

We've all seen them - the talented players who either get intimidated by aggressive fans in away matches or collapse under the weight of expectation, best articulated by Tony Cascarino in his hilarious autobiography. (Tony, you were so funny that I forgave you for the way you performed for us.)

Tuesday saw some do just that. The younger players, we can excuse completely. One or two more established professionals should enjoy no such indulgence.

None of the players at the Camp Nou would gain pass marks. But this was an occasion on which we saw the real “men and boys” in our own team.

Saturday was particularly enjoyable because, when the volume was cranked up to 11, we saw a team with belief in themselves, confidence in their coaches and trust in each other. On such occasions, stars rise.

And it will come as no surprise that the brightest of them all on Saturday was Moussa Dembele.

When we signed a young striker with a solid English championship season behind him, I was encouraged and pleasantly surprised. It was the sort of signing many of us had been asking for in the "on plan" years.

When he stepped up to take that penalty against Astana, many of us who had been around for a while sensed a defining moment.

Saturday was another great test, passed with flying colours and, despite being “psyched out” by the Barca keeper Ter Stegen and placing a mid-level penalty, I have no criticism of him.
Moussa has strength, close control and the ability to combine both to hold the ball in the six-yard box under intense pressure from defenders.

It is exactly the sort of skill that one former Celtic striker, now sadly reduced to being a SkySports pundit, once said he had tried to copy from Kenny Dalglish, believing that the tight confines of the playground had been an ideal training ground. (Not, not you, Andy Walker, nobody is interested in your playing style - I'm talking about Charlie Nicholas.)

People quite rightly talked about the variety of goals from Saturday but another indication of Dembele's quality was his ability to bring difficult long passes under control with his chest.

That doesn't just demonstrate learned technique but the ability to remain calm while 60,000 people are screaming at you.

And I saw no indication that he was dealing with the Camp Nou atmosphere any less well than anyone else. Playing a lone striker role against the world's best team – which is hamering your teammates behind you – is a tough task and Moussa was not the worst player on display.

Tuesday could have crushed the spirit of the team but there are still positive signs.

We have, in varying measures, skill, speed, solidity, creativity and versatility, but not enough of any of them yet. We are a long way from being a top team, as Barcelona showed – but then they have done something similar to genuinely top teams (like Valencia).

But the general direction is positive.

We faced a monumentally difficult task in Barcelona on Tuesday – and we failed.

Let's be clear - anything professional and competitive against Barca would have been a success. None of our players left with their reputations enhanced but while the occasion was too early for some, a few at least fought until the end – as always, Scott Brown – and a few let us down both in terms of performance level and courage (also known as commitment).

I expect that their names have been duly noted by the coaching staff and that they will follow some of their “team hangover” colleagues out the door when an opportunity arises.

You can make mistakes, you can play badly – not acceptable but understandable. If you play for Celtic, you better have the pride and moral courage to conspicuously give everything when things are going against you – for your teammates, your coaches and the fans.

If your hamstring has once troubled you so badly that you signalled to the bench when struggling with your lower-division rivals – and then recovered when you realised your team had used all three subs – you had better make the most of the privilege of representing Celtic against the world's finest footballers.

If an easy win makes you so cocky that you want to run around with a beachball on your head, then don't try to be the invisible clown three days later, when real footballers are running your team ragged – and real men are doing their best to try to combat it.

We have seen two mismatches over the last five days, bringing joy and discomfort to us, in equal measure.

Yet, they have both been great football occasions in their own way, because, despite the malicious jibes of those small-minded officials of a small-time club, overwhelmingly the fans made them so.

Those same fans make football – and footballers – something.

It is encouraging that almost all of our players over the two games recognised that.

Brendan Rodgers poignantly quoted Jock Stein on Saturday on the 31st anniversary of Jock's death (and the fifth anniversary of Brendan's own father).

Brendan and his coaching team – so strong on detail and so demanding of intensity – will surely be reinforcing some of Jock's simple values over the coming months.

--

Thursday, August 04, 2016

Echoes of the past and green shoots of trust for Brendan Rodgers and Celtic

There is something in the air around Celtic Park at the moment, for now little more than a faint aroma but it's growing.

Brendan Rodgers asked Celtic fans to trust the players after another night when questions were asked but the right answers were delivered.
Young Team: Eoghan O'Connell and Moussa Dembele

It was far from a perfect performance and there were a few players who illustrated why Brendan is still said to be pursuing four other signings – but more of them another time. This is a time to be positive.

He is right in everything he says about fans' impatience creating extra pressure and anxiety. That leads to players making mistakes and it is only natural that a manager should try to do everything to create an atmosphere that allows his team to perform at its best.

But that trust is already slowly starting to build. If Brendan doesn't realise that, he should have been around last year.

For the past two seasons, many of the same players who were on display last night screwed up almost every time they were faced with a major test.

Fans were becoming accustomed to it. But there are signs that improvement is already being made.

There is an increasing sense that the players understand what is expected of them  – both in terms of their roles and commitment – in a way that had been missing.

That lends confidence to the fans and, if understandably nervous, most seem to be getting back that sense of belief in the team.

It will take time – and consistent professional performances – to fully restore that trust but the green shoots of hope are there.

Kieran Tierney, Eoghan O'Connell and Patrick Roberts continue to impress but honourable mention must also go to Saidy Janko who showed some of the ability that caused Manchester United fans to have such high hopes for him before he was thrust into a transitional defence at Celtic.

There are areas for improvement in his game, such as his decision making, but, crucially, he looked like a player who could develop with the sort of quality coaching most of us believe we now have at the club.

And I can't be the only one to have waited for Moussa Dembele to take that penalty, thinking that we were about to witness a pivotal moment in his career.

My mind went back to the story of a 20-year-old Kenny Dalglish tying his lace before scoring a penalty against Rangers for his first competitive goal.

Kenny later admitted that it wasn't because he was cool-as-a-cucumber but instead he was taking the chance to steady his nerves.

We don't know how far Dembele will progress but we do not need to doubt his nerve on the big occasion ever again.

Kolo Toure also brought a sense of assurance to all around him although, ironically, the goal was conceded a few minutes after he went on. We seem to have a new top-drawer defensive coach but, this time, he's on the pitch – and he can play a bit as well.

But, for me, the most surprising change was in Scott Brown. I have long been an admirer and
Play it Kolo: Toure calls for calm
defender of Brown, often taking pelters for my troubles.

I was even once harangued for having mentioned him in the same article as Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard although no direct comparison was ever made.

So I was amused to read Brendan comparing Scott to Gerrard in terms of leadership and commitment to the club.

Before he took a single match, Brendan replied, “150% yes”, to questions about whether the club captain would remain. When you hear the manager then praising him for tactical understanding and playing ability that even he hadn't expected him to have, you can finally put the constant critics to bed.

Last night's was a different performance from Scott, apparently free from being the sole input of drive in the team, trying to force play with sheer energy.

He seemed to have more time on the ball than on any occasion I can imagine, no doubt helped by the improved organisation Brendan Rodgers has brought to the team.

With that, came probably his best night in terms of ball distribution that I have ever seen from him – both long and short passing with both feet, including one 35-yard pass to put Leigh Griffiths through on goal.

Brendan has said Scott can be the playmaker and – pelters at the ready, now – there were even shades of Paul McStay in his readiness to take pressure off his teammates, switch play and create opportunities.

None of this need be taken as premature predictions of greatness for the team or individual players.

What we have are signs of progress and with them, early seeds of trust. It will be continued progress that will allow that trust to grow.

And then the sky's the limit. We may even start talking about hope.
--

Monday, April 18, 2016

Legitimate questions for Scott Brown as Celtic captain

Firstly – and this is likely to disappoint some – this will not be a diatribe against Scott Brown.

Scott has his detractors – even “haters” – amongst the Celtic support. The latter group have been comprised of some of the most unthinking Celtic fans I have ever known. The sort who harboured ridiculous suspicions and nurtured them as all evidence rendered them absurd.

Brown has his faults, notably a tendency to carelessly give the ball away through slack passing that I always expected him to iron out. But, though that has been a perennial flaw, we're not talking Steven Gerrard bad.

No, but his use of the ball in the middle of the field has always been the major flaw in his armoury, even if he did “boss” that area against England's Gerrard and Frank Lampard in 2013 (a contribution that both of those English midfielders were generous enough to acknowledge – it was a friendly, after all).

The next year, Gordon Strachan watched his team claim an unlikely equaliser before replacing Brown with the returning Darren Fletcher, conveniently side-stepping the issue of who should be the permanent captain. A Scotland team, outgunned in the first half, immediately collapsed.

When faced with a performance, such as the one Scott turned in at the weekend, it is understandable that criticism should be directed towards him. And he has rarely sustained his top form over the past two or three seasons.

  • The first question is: Why has his form rarely matched his experience, endeavour and aggression in recent times?
  • The second is: Why, for all his passion, energy and standing within the game, do the Celtic players never seem to respond in times of adversity?
  • Question number three is: Is this the (beginning of) the end?

Only Scott Brown can answer questions one and two but I''ll add my tuppence-worth.

I suspect that injuries and even excessive loyalty account for much of question one.

It is no secret that Brown has sustained a number of injuries and been left in that terrible players' dilemma of missing games in order to fully recover or play, through pain and slightly diminished ability, when performance margins are slim. [See update below 02/05/16]

That's a tough call for both player and manager. I recall Jock Stein praising Graeme Souness for offering to play with a pain-killing injection in his toe. Jock chose to think of the player's welfare first.

With Brown, one of the reasons that those who doubt his character should hang their heads in shame is that, above all, he has shown loyalty both to his teams and managers.

Brown stood alone in standing up for Ronny Deila when the press vultures were first circling. He also turned out for Celtic and Scotland, dropping hints that his international career might come to an end.

Many a professional has done the same thing, extending his club career by allowing his body the rest time that it needs.

It is no secret that Gordon Strachan urged him to remain the central mainstay of the Scotland team and Mark McGhee's recent comment that Brown had been the stand-out player of the Strachan era should not be taken lightly.

The best thing for Scott Brown's body and reputation would be to announce his international retirement, rest and play to something like his full potential for Celtic. He seems to have chosen the harder option.

It could also be speculated that his coaching interests may have further distracted him from developing his game but that would be to play the devil's advocate.

This is all speculation.

To question number two, there seem to be three possible answers:

1. Brown lacks leadership skills or credibility with his teammates
2. He is surrounded by a group of players so spineless as to be impossible to encourage
3. There is so little belief instilled by the coaching staff that it is impossible for an on-field leader to compensate for it.

My view is that number one can be ruled out due to the fact that the last four Celtic managers have named him as captain, one making him captain of the national team.

Number two is, sadly, more credible. Anyone who has watched the flat performances, the mysterious injuries, the players who would rather go to UFC fights than watch their teammates or who have gone into hiding when the pressure was on would doubt the mettle of the senior players.

But it's rarely wise to make swathing generalisations.

Number three is more vexing. Ronny Deila sets great store by his ability to lead, develop and inspire players.

But reactions on the field of play – as well as reticence when the head coach needed support (and outrageous abuse by Kris Commons) – suggest that the lack of belief may well come from the bench.

Can a captain give courage when the accepted senior leadership cannot? Roy Aitken was famous for urging his charges on for club and country, not least in the centenary double season. But, then he had Billy McNeill as his manager for most of that time – and Alex Ferguson for Scotland.

The question of this being the beginning of the end is a more delicate one.

I believe that Brown can have two or three years as Celtic captain (maybe four). But, if he insists on going through another Scotland international campaign, that scenario will be increasingly unlikely.

At this stage, he should have deputies, people ready to take on the responsibility of running the midfield, allowing Brown respite – to play 75 minutes, instead of the last punishing 15, when his body is tired and hurting.

And that is what a less loyal, less courageous player might seek. It's hard to imagine Brown holding his hamstring, gesturing to the bench that he has to come off and making a miraculous recovery when he realised that there was no sub to allow him to leave the pitch.

I'm a Scott Brown fan – I admit that. And this may be taken in that context.

But I just don't see the performances we have seen from Brown in recent times reflecting the true player, fit and on form.

At a time when many of us have been calling for guts, maybe we should consider what the most courageous player at the club is taking for the team.



--

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

Tom Boyd – the ambassador's reception is understandably mixed

26th August 1998. It would be an exaggeration to say that Celtic fans' three months of joy – following nine years of pain – had come crashing to an end. The preceding weeks had been more traumatic than that.

Wim Jansen had walked, throwing as much dirt as he possibly could in the direction of Fergus McCann, Jock Brown and “Brown's man”, Eric Black.

Murdo McLeod had volubly spat the dummy in the same direction after he had failed to be anointed Jansen's successor and a search for a replacement manager – with Gerard Houllier, John Toshack and a host of other “big names” splashed across the sports pages had resulted in the appointment of Dr Jozef Vengloš.

Predictably, the sort of people who could confidently state that Celtic would appoint Artur Jorge, greeted the appointment with derision, labelling it “a farce”, “an embarrassment”, “a shambles”. You name it – they said it of the process through which Lubomir Moravcik would eventually be enticed to the club.


Any residual euphoria or belief that Celtic's troubles were behind them were duly Scotched that night, with an abject performance. It was a display worthy of a protest with a hapless captain allowing Silvio Marić the easiest of opportunities to open the scoring before giving away a penalty to dispel all doubt before half-time.
Bad night for the captain: and Celtic went two goals down

A tough night, which even very good players endure sometimes. You might have expected that captain to apologise to the fans, tell them that the team's performance, as well as his own, had not been good enough.

You might have imagined a strident defence of the manager and a promise to the supporters that this would not be repeated.

But, no, because what we got – to the further delight of the Scottish sports media – was a string of “no comments”.

But that was understandable. After all, the players who had just let down the club so badly were unhappy with the first ever Champions League bonus payment which would have been due to be paid to any Celtic players.

Years of several of the same squad having been party to some humiliating performances by Celtic had apparently been wiped out by one league title that had become so rare that it was deemed to be as precious as a Faberge egg.
The Jimmy Johnstone Faberge Egg

Vengloš was left alone to face a howling, gleeful press pack with the twin weapons of a crushing defeat and an excuse to attack Fergus McCann. Vengloš was as decent a man as you could have wished for: dignified, knowledgeable, experienced and respected in the game.

It was a shameful episode in the history of the club. Vengloš would face a torrid season of cruel attacks including the fiasco of signing a player from that very Zagreb team, Mark Viduka, who promptly got on a plane to Australia and tried to wriggle out of the move.

There were credible stories of players, whose technical abilities didn't match Vengloš's aspirations for the team, actively undermining him.

There has never, to my knowledge, been an accusation that the captain was one of them but I struggle to recall any robust defences of Vengloš, the like of which Scott Brown has laudably offered for Ronny Deila.

Oh, and the captain? He went on to be a “legend” by the name of Tom Boyd.

Boyd was, overall, an excellent player for Celtic – let's be absolutely clear about that. And, more, he has often been one of the few ex-players to challenge the negative press narrative surrounding all things Celtic.

Arriving two years before McCann, Boyd's career covered the ridiculous through to the sublime when Larsson, Sutton and Moravcik were running fine teams ragged and taunting city rivals.

But our newly-appointed club ambassador seems to look back on those days through a curiously selective lens, when using them for perspective against which to judge current “hysteria”.

“You only have to go back to the days when I first came to this football club and we couldn’t even finish in second place. We don’t have a divine right to win every game; to win every league.”

The latter comment is one of many straw-man arguments put forward by those who brook no criticism. I have yet to hear any fan claiming a “divine right” to win – only a constant ambition to do so.

Boyd seems to forget that it was sack-the-board “hysteria” that finally drove out a self-serving and incompetent board of directors and contributed to him winning the many honours he enjoyed at Celtic.

“Criticism doesn’t help out on the pitch. Players start to hide and don’t show for the ball. The most important thing is that the players and management get encouragement and unity.”

I'm sure I recall Billy McNeill making similar pleas and the anguish caused to a true Celtic great, who could also see that change was needed at the club, even while the anger of the fans was creating an often-toxic atmosphere in the ground, which could only have affected the players.

“Maybe defensively, Celtic haven’t been as good but there are a number of reasons for that. Last season, there was a settled defence with Virgil van Dijk and Jason Denayer,” Boyd goes on as if the fans don't know that we cashed in on one defender, knowing that the other wasn't our player.

That's a defence of Ronny Deila but not of the management of the club. And this is part of the issue that so many fans have with the comments from Boyd, a man of whom there was scarcely a negative word said before his latest intervention.

Celtic seem to be determined to go to war with a growing section of the club's fans, leaving them casualties in pursuit of a corporate plan. In doing so, there is room for suspicion that they are seeking allies from amongst the club's most respected servants to create division, despite Boyd's ironic call for unity.

Celtic fans don't need the club to tell us who our ambassadors are. We have always known – they have earned our trust sufficiently for us to believe they speak for the good of the club as a whole, 
starting with the fans and the team; not simply representing the executive view that they are "really spoiling us".

McNeill, Auld, McGrain, Burns, Aitken, McStay, Larsson, Moravcik and, yes, even Strachan – all ambassadors without having needed a title. In fact, the club ought not to think that by turning an accolade into a position of official authority, they can take ownership of it as a tool for the marketing and communications departments.

If the ambassadors get some sort of payment or benefit, good luck to them. If that impinges on their ability to speak out when things are wrong, they risk becoming people whose words the fans will view with increasing distrust.

Peter Lawwell: Is he really spoiling us?
Some ex-players, such as Sutton, Walker, McCleod and Provan are have had their reputations irreparably tarnished for unfairly abusing the club.

Other's reputations may suffer the same fate if they take potshots at fans who care about the club, all to please people who appear to be letting us down with a “plan” that is highly suspect.

“People were craving competition in Scottish football. Do people really want that? If the minute you get a close competition you then say, ‘crisis’ for a club sitting at the top of the league, do you really want the competition?”

The implied accusation of hypocrisy amongst the “lifeblood of the game” – the fans – should be duly noted.

Tom, there are two ways to achieve competition – encourage a raising of general standards or let the best team deteriorate – and it is insulting to the intelligence of fans to suggest that they cannot distinguish between the two or see which of the two options is currently in effect.
--